Defining what makes a photograph or work of art truly “great” is like trying to grasp a fleeting wisp of smoke, it’s elusive, subjective, and deeply personal. It’s a question that has perplexed artists and enthusiasts for centuries, one that delves into the depths of human perception and emotion.

Consider the realm of art: Jackson Pollock’s abstract splatter paintings or Yoko Ono’s avant-garde installations often evoke polarized reactions. Some view them as masterpieces of expression, while others dismiss them as chaotic or even nonsensical.

Photography, as a form of visual art, is no exception to this diverse spectrum of interpretation. The question arises: Is photography primarily a technical discipline, governed by rules of exposure and composition, or does it embrace artistic freedom, allowing for experimentation with techniques like intentional camera movement and creative post-processing?

At its core, the essence of a great photograph or artwork lies in its ability to resonate with the viewer on a deeply personal level. It transcends mere technical proficiency or adherence to conventional norms; it speaks to the soul, evoking emotions, memories, and contemplation.

Recently, I found myself drawn to an online community called 100ASA — an oasis amidst the cacophony of social media platforms driven by likes and superficial validation. Unlike its counterparts, 100ASA fosters a culture of thoughtful engagement, where members curate each other’s work to earn points for their own. This deliberate process encourages introspection and growth, challenging photographers to consider not just the technical aspects of their images but also the emotional resonance they evoke.

So, what are the ingredients that elevate a photograph from mere pixels to a work of art that lingers in the mind long after it’s been viewed? Is there a formula, a checklist, or a set of criteria? While these may offer some guidance, the truth is that the magic of great photography defies quantification.

Perhaps it’s the story behind the image — the narrative it conveys or the emotions it elicits. Or maybe it’s the subject matter itself — the focal point that draws the eye and captures the imagination. It could be the artist’s unique vision — the mood, atmosphere, and perspective they bring to their work. Composition, framing, patterns, textures, lines, structure — each element plays a role in shaping the visual experience.

And then there’s light and colour — the twin pillars that breathe life into a photograph, infusing it with warmth, depth, and dimension. Whether it’s the soft glow of a sunset casting long shadows or the vibrant hues of a bustling cityscape, light and colour have the power to transform the ordinary into the extraordinary.

But ultimately, the true measure of a great photograph lies in its ability to connect with the viewer — to evoke an emotional response, to spark a conversation, to leave a lasting impression. It’s about that intangible quality — that unexplainable magic — that draws us in and holds our attention.

In the end, great photography is not just about technical proficiency or aesthetic beauty; it’s about storytelling, emotion, and connection. It’s about capturing moments that resonate with the soul and inspire us to see the world in a new light. And in a world inundated with images, it’s these rare gems that stand out, shining brightly amidst the noise and clamour.